Rice University’s Student Newspaper — Since 1916

Tuesday, March 28, 2023 — Houston, TX

CDOD hosts conversation on Fizz

dei-fizz-katherine-hui-web
Katherine Hui / Thresher

By Maria Morkas     3/7/23 9:34pm

The Office of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion hosted a conversation about Fizz, an anonymous social media platform, as a continuation of the Critical Dialogues on Diversity series. Panelists spoke about the dangers of anonymity, impacts on the culture of care and how the conversations on the app are representative of the student body as a whole.

Angelina Hall, a teaching assistant for CDOD and diversity facilitator, served as one of the panelists for the discussion. She co-wrote an opinion piece about Fizz and the culture of care last fall. Hall spoke about the dangers of the app, including her own experiences and specific conversation themes she has noticed. 

“There have been a lot of conversations about body shaming and fatphobia; there was a conversation chain that went on for about two weeks while we were on winter break about that topic,” Hall, a Brown College junior, said. “I feel like this happens quite a lot and very often, and it has been taking place since Fizz first got to campus last semester.” 



Professor of anthropology Baird Campbell, another panelist, spoke about the theory behind dialectics, social media and why the combination of the two makes regulating Fizz a difficult topic to approach.

“[Dialectics] are defined by the fact that they can’t be resolved,” Campbell said. “This is the issue with there being so many of them in the structure of social media… there really isn’t a great answer for what to do to make this really way better or different.”

Campbell said that he believes the darkest places on the internet are often anonymous. 

“Once you’re totally anonymous, you can sort of do whatever you want. And people have to decide whether they’re going to trust or distrust you. They’re going to have to decide whether they want to spend their time engaging with [the anonymous entity],” Campbell said. “And ultimately, the more and more of this process there is, the less likely we are to be able to moderate it meaningfully do anything about it.”

Jazmine Castillo also served as a panelist to the discussion and shared her experiences with fatphobia and discriminatory messages against minorities on Fizz. She wrote an article about fatphobia following a discussion on Fizz over winter break.

“A lot of things that are being discussed are not just conversations that are happening on Fizz but lived experiences by people on this campus,” Castillo, a McMurtry College senior, said. “And oftentimes, the anonymity that empowers the people to say derogatory or discriminatory comments on Fizz is the same anonymity that allows people to respond to them.”

Campbell said he encourages students to consider what Rice’s culture of care really means.

“Right here in Texas, forms of  ‘care’ have been used to justify incarcerating migrants, racialized policing, and banning access to reproductive healthcare,” Campbell said. “In short, to say that your culture is one of ‘care’ doesn’t mean much in and of itself. The controversy generated about Fizz seems like an invitation to the campus community to define exactly what our values are, perhaps grounded in the idea of [culture of care]. That is: what does the Rice community—and the Rice administration—stand for, and what does it stand against?”



More from The Rice Thresher

NEWS 3/21/23 10:39pm
Muslim students and H&D prepare for Ramadan

The Muslim holy month of Ramadan begins this week, falling between March 22 to April 20 this year, overlapping with events such as Beer Bike and the end of the semester. Observers fast from dawn until dusk, which is approximately 13 hours in Houston, to practice spiritual devotedness.

NEWS 3/21/23 10:38pm
Beer Bike to divide races amid safety concerns

Beer Bike races will be held in two heats this year, instead of the traditional singular race, according to Anne Wang, a campus-wide Beer Bike coordinator. The change is in light of last year’s crash during the women’s race, which injured three bikers and sent one to the hospital.

NEWS 3/21/23 10:36pm
Administration affirms commitment to diversity

President Reginald DesRoches announced Rice’s commitment to diversity ahead of anticipated Supreme Court rulings on affirmative action cases in a campus-wide email sent on March 3, cosigned by Provost Amy Dittmar and Vice Provost for Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Alexander Byrd. 


Comments

Please note All comments are eligible for publication by The Rice Thresher.