O-Week PAAs will no longer be affiliated with O-Week groups
Beginning the fall of 2020, Orientation Week Peer Academic Advisors will no longer also serve as O-Week advisors. The Office of Academic Advising instituted this change to lower the mental and physical strain for students chosen for those positions, according to Aliya Bhimani.
Bhimani, director of the OAA, said these changes would be reverting to an older model, as opposed to turning to an untested system.
“For more than 15 years this exact structure was in place without issue. It wasn’t until the past few O-Weeks that we experimented with a model that attached O-Week PAAs to O-Week groups,” Bhimani said.
According to Bhimani, there is a heavy workload that comes with being both an O-Week PAA and advisor. O-Week PAAs are currently responsible for both academic and social aspects of O-Week, as they must plan academic meetings and help set up incoming freshmen’s schedule while also being ready to help integrate and welcome new students into a new college environment.
“After running the experiment, we have found that the original model actually worked very well for us,” Bhimani said. “It allowed the O-Week PAAs to serve in an elevated leadership role with ample time to focus on the academic components of O-Week and assist all incoming freshmen at their residential colleges.”
Jones College senior Shami Mosely was an O-Week PAA twice: once as part of an O-Week group and the other as a floater. Mosely said he chose to be the test subject for Jones O-Week in 2018 as the only PAA not assigned to a group. “I did enjoy being an O-Week PAA more when I was in an O-Week group. I just felt isolated when I wasn’t in an O-Week group,” Mosely said.
According to Smeet Madhani, a senior from Will Rice College, having to juggle both roles added additional strain on the already strenuous environment of O-Week.
“[O-Week is] busy for everyone, but I think that having to have a dual role put a lot of stress on trying to make sure that as an O-Week PAA we’re completing our duties,” Madhani said.
According to Madhani, while PAAs have to juggle the workload of being an advisor, such as making crafts, learning the college dances and attending meetings, they also had to attend lengthy PAA training.
“We’re not only working with the OAA, we’re working with the magisters, the divisional advisors, all the advisors and a lot of other collaborative offices, and that all starts during training,” Madhani said. “As an advisor you’re also preparing for O-Week, and it’s hard for the advisors to pick up the work you’re not doing when you’re also preparing to be a PAA.”
However, former Will Rice O-Week coordinator Colin Chan said that he believes that making interpersonal relationships with new students is an integral part of being a successful PAA and removing that connection could cause PAAs to become less successful in their role.
“I do think having a close personal relationship with students through an advising group is important because it gives the PAA a very easy way to link into the relational network of O-Week. As floaters, I feel that it might be hard for some PAA’s to really get to know the new students,” Chan said.
Chan also mentioned that it might be difficult to find four qualified individuals per college that fit the qualifications of the new system, at least for the upcoming year.
Edesiri Mushale, a former O-Week coordinator, said he believes this change could be beneficial, as PAAs may find it tricky to both connect with their new students and focus on their academic duties. He also said that the added stress of the intense workload can cause a divide between the PAAs themselves.
“I do know that my PAAs were always under a lot of stress and working all the time, and that even caused divides between the PAAs themselves, as some people would try to pander towards the advisor job or the PAA job more,” Mushale, a McMurtry College junior, said.
Jones College junior and O-Week PAA Hannah Kim said she is curious and hopeful to see how much more the PAAs will actually be able to do, but she also is unsure how this change will affect a PAA’s performance. According to Kim, most of a PAA’s work is during advisor training. Kim believes that a possible negative impact of PAAs being attached to an advising group is a strained team dynamic, which she hasn’t experienced.
“On one hand, because O-Week PAAs have their separate trainings and duties during advisor training, it can be hard for us to hang out and work with our advising team,” Kim said. “I imagine this change is meant to give PAAs more time to do their tasks, dedicate more individualized attention to new students, and balance their wellbeing during training and O-Week. And if that really happens, then it sounds like only beneficial things can come out of this change.
More from The Rice Thresher
Students returning to campus in the upcoming fall semester will have to adjust to a number of precautionary changes all subject to change, such as rearranged housing, bathroom schedules and mandated COVID-19 testing, implemented in efforts to protect against the spread of COVID-19, according to an email sent July 1 by Dean of Undergraduates Bridget Gorman.
The Lovett College Orientation Week coordinator team reopened advisor applications to add additional advisors and to create an additional O-Week team after some students raised concerns about a lack of Black advisors at Lovett. This comes after previous years in which residential college advising teams have been criticized for lacking diversity.
“We cannot ignore the very real and very problematic history of the man who founded this institution,” Gabrielle Falcon (Martel ‘20) said. “Progress is inevitable and I would hope that Rice would do its best to join the wave of progress we have been seeing this summer, instead of making pointed decisions to prevent it from flourishing.”