After exclusion from aid expansion, international students seek support
For Jerry Wu, an international student from Shanghai, China, excluding international students from The Rice Investment reflects how they are less visible and “to some extent neglected” at Rice.
“The Rice Investment ends up dividing the Rice community in terms of drawing such a clear line between domestic and international students,” Wu, a Sid Richardson College junior, said.
The reasons for excluding international students from The Rice Investment are practical, according to Yvonne Romero da Silva, vice president for enrollment.
“Because [The Rice Investment’s] brackets of low and middle incomes in the U.S. can often be equivalent to the wealthier classes in many foreign countries, it did not seem appropriate to simply apply The Rice Investment to our international student population,” da Silva said in an email. “Instead, we rely on our rigorous need-based analysis to assess the financial need of our international students according to their specific circumstances.”
According to da Silva, as part of a goal stated in the Vision for the Second Century, Second Decade, Rice University will undertake fundraising efforts to improve financial aid for international students in the next capital campaign, which will also raise funds for The Rice Investment and other priorities in the V2C2.
Xianglin Zhang, an international student from Changsha, China, said she was “pissed off” when she realized The Rice Investment plan excludes international students.
“I was super excited because I knew I would definitely be qualified for [the plan],” Zhang, a Lovett College freshman, said. “But then I went to the FAQ tab and I opened it and it said it doesn't apply to international students. I was just so disappointed. By saying 'for every Rice student,' I think it implies that international students should be included, but it turns out it doesn't.”
Members of the Rice International Student Association will meet with President David Leebron, Dean of Undergraduates Bridget Gorman, da Silva and the Office of Financial Aid after midterm recess at the latest regarding the exclusion of international students from The Rice Investment, according to Chenlin Huang, president of RISA.
“We were intending to have a town hall meeting with [them] where students can have a conversation with the Rice administration in person,” Huang, a Lovett junior, said in an email. “Both President Leebron and Dean Gorman responded and suggested to meet in a smaller format with the student representatives.”
RISA posted about the meeting on its Facebook page on Saturday and included a Google Form for students to submit questions regarding The Rice Investment plan, financial aid and the affordability of Rice for international students.
Zhang said she filled out the spreadsheet sent by RISA with two questions for the administration: “Would The Rice Investment be open to international students, and if so, when?” and “What will Rice do to help international students in the meantime?”
Rice does not offer need-blind admission to international students, which means an applicant’s ability to fund their attendance is considered during the admissions process, according to da Silva. This is not true for domestic students, who are admitted regardless of financial need. In addition, da Silva said only international applicants who sought aid and were admitted with aid can apply for financial aid in future years.
“This is a common practice among U.S. colleges and universities, including many top-ranked schools like Stanford, Brown and Columbia,” da Silva said. “Even institutions that practice need-blind admission for international students often cap the number of international students they admit to limit the amount of financial aid awarded to international students. Rice‘s approach is designed in part to achieve a substantial representation of international students in the undergraduate student body.”
Shuxin Zhang, an international student from Tianjin, China, said she did not apply for financial aid at Rice. Zhang said last summer a close family member was diagnosed with cancer and could no longer work, reducing her family's income, but she was not eligible to apply for aid because she didn’t apply for aid during the admissions process.
"I cannot imagine if someone who is already on the financial margin to have some misfortunes as I am having right now; that would be not only a loss but a disaster,” Zhang, a Lovett senior, said. “Rice doesn't have to support me because I'm still financially eligible to complete my studies at Rice, but Rice should help someone in a more severe situation."
Noor El Sonbaty, an international student from Alexandria, Egypt, said he founded RISA with Huang and two other students last year and will attend the meeting with the administration. El Sonbaty said inflation in Egypt a few years ago caused the cost of tuition for his family to double or triple.
“There are so many moving parts,” El Sonbaty, a Will Rice College senior, said. “The university might raise tuition or Egypt's economy might be unstable. It's kind of like, 'I'm here, but I don't know how long I'm going to be here for.' Thankfully, I know my family can financially support me, but that is not always the case for other people.”
Five colleges in the United States — Harvard University, Yale University, Princeton University, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Amherst College — offer need-blind admissions and full financial aid to international undergraduate students, according to several websites including Forbes and TopUniversities.
Over the past 10 years, Rice has quadrupled the amount of financial aid provided to international students to almost $4 million, according to da Silva. Since 2009, da Silva said the number of international students receiving aid has doubled. This year, 13 percent of the incoming freshman class are international students.
“While this program is not available to international students, Rice remains committed to welcoming them to the university and to supporting them while they are here,” da Silva said.
Wu said he hopes the administration can reassure international students in their meeting that their tuition and fees will not rise as a result of The Rice Investment — a concern he said is widespread among international students.
“International students are completely left out of the conversation, so it hurts a little,” Wu said. “On the other hand, I can understand this decision partially because there is an unwritten understanding that usually international students do not receive financial aid or scholarships.”
The Rice Investment will have no impact on tuition, as financial aid is solely funded by annual donations and endowment proceeds and no tuition revenue is used to provide financial aid for other students, according to da Silva.
Niky Bao, an international student from Beijing, said a counterargument for providing aid to international students could be that they are less likely to give back to Rice. Bao said if Rice supports international students now, they will be more likely to give in the future.
“If [The Rice Investment] stays what it is, people will remember how in college they had really good years but their families have to bear a lot for them to come here,” Bao, a Hanszen College junior, said. “When they become rich, maybe they will set up a separate fund for international students — just aid for international students only, which we don't want because Rice is Rice. It's for everyone, no matter if you're international or not.”
More from The Rice Thresher
Following an opinion piece by former Students Turning Rice Into a Violence-Free Environment liaison Sarah Park which called for organizational reform, the Thresher reached out to several STRIVE affiliates to further investigate the claims made and discuss STRIVE’s mission and the whisper network.
Alongside the student expansion, the administration plans to add around 50 faculty members with diversity in mind, according to President David Leebron.
The Abercrombie Engineering Laboratory will be demolished and replaced by a new engineering and science building beginning this May. Demolition will start mid-May and construction of the new building will be substantially complete in January 2023, according to Associate Vice President for Facilities Engineering and Planning Kathy Jones.