Rice University’s Student Newspaper — Since 1916

Sunday, July 03, 2022 — Houston, TX

Review: ‘The Guilty’ disappoints in comparison to the original

the-guilty-photo-courtesy-netflix
Photo courtesy Netflix

By Will Cover     10/5/21 11:53pm

Review: ★★

There’s been a much-maligned trend in movies lately where studios take old, beloved intellectual property and reboot it for modern audiences. “The Guilty” presents something of an interesting experiment from Netflix, then. Although it’s an almost exact remake of a Danish movie of the same name, the original is neither old (it was released just three years ago) or beloved (while it opened to critical acclaim, it made just 4.6 million dollars). Theoretically, this should simplify the path to success for an adaptation. Despite this, “The Guilty” comes nowhere near surpassing an excellent original. 

“The Guilty,” which is now streaming on Netflix, follows Joe Baylor (Jake Gyllenhaal), a police officer temporarily forced to work at a 911 call center because of misconduct. Baylor receives a call from a woman kidnapped who must talk in code to not alert her captor, and the rest of the movie depicts his attempt to rescue this woman, all over the phone. This basic setup allows for an interesting concept: almost the entirety of the movie takes place in the call center, with Baylor’s callers only heard and never seen. 



When looking at the successfulness of a remake, a useful jumping off point is considering why the remake should have been made. The lack of an answer to this question is perhaps “The Guilty”’s fatal flaw. Director Antoine Fuqua presents no clear vision that couldn’t be better found in the Danish version. The details of the plot are almost identical, often with dialogue blatantly cribbed from the Danish subtitles. Where Fuqua largely differentiates his entry is in the treatment of these details, as the emotional beats within “The Guilty” lose all their subtlety from the original in exchange for overbearing clarity. 

This can perhaps best be seen in Gyllenhaal’s performance. “The Guilty” depends on Gyllenhaal hitting it out of the park, as lead Jakob Cedergren does in the original, because the camera is focused closely on Gyllenhaal in almost every shot. Gyllenhaal is certainly no stranger to acclaimed performances and has taken the unsettling roles (see “Nightcrawler”) which make him seem to be a natural fit for the role. He certainly goes for it here, trying to scream, wheeze and ugly cry his way to an emotional reaction from the viewer. 

Despite what the acting clips at the Oscars might lead you to believe, though, not every line should be read with a pained bombasity. This is the area where “The Guilty” pales most in comparison to the original; Gyllenhaal is fine, but he just can’t keep up with Cedergen’s dominating performance. When Gyllenhaal turns it up to 11, it carries less weight because so much of his acting is already near an extreme. And, when he finally tries to be reserved, it consequently comes across just as emotionless. Cedergren, meanwhile, has frustration and contempt for others always bubbling under the surface, which enhances the power of his more sparse outbursts. 

Another strength of the original, the sound design, falls flat here. With so much of the plot told over the phone, impeccable sound design is necessary to create a rich story. Again, Fuqua chooses to eschew any subtlety for the common trope of a heartbeat or ear ringing sound effect to try and ramp up the drama. The only impression this left, however, is that Fuqua didn’t trust in the performances of his actors nor the viewer’s ability to understand something as obvious as “if Baylor gets in a screaming match, he’ll probably be rattled afterward.” 

Given the places “The Guilty” falls short of its original, it’s worth examining where it chooses to differentiate itself in the plot. The most egregious instance of this is in the greater time Fuqua devotes to Baylor’s misconduct as an officer, which is a tricky topic done without a deft hand. This version appears to hope the audience sympathizes with Baylor despite his wrongdoing and makes his misconduct a thematic focus. Even with the additional time given to the topic, I was left feeling it was rushed, an issue I didn’t have with the original. Police brutality carries a much greater political importance in an American movie than a Danish one, and confining it to a pseudo-thematic sublot doesn’t give this topic the time that it needs. 

Consistently throughout “The Guilty,” I was left either confused or disappointed at how Fuqua and Gyllenhaal approached an amazing original. Rather than trusting the audience to understand and appreciate subtlety, they led the viewer to water and tried to waterboard them in a story that has the potential for such rich emotion. In a vacuum, “The Guilty” is mediocre at best, but it becomes distinctly bad when considering the much better source it copied.



More from The Rice Thresher

A&E 4/19/22 11:35pm
Summer Book Recommendations

With summer right around the corner, many students’ brains will finally have space for things other than organic chemistry or the latest coding problem that needs to be solved. Take this time to read for enjoyment again. The following are a series of summer recommendations perfect for time on a plane, by the pool or just on your couch. All incorporate travel in one way or another, and each has its own adventure that will leave you yearning for more. 

A&E 4/19/22 11:32pm
Review:‘The Northman’ sees Robert Eggers take his work to a larger stage

Robert Eggers is a filmmaker whose work has been defined by its small scale and intensive focus on characters. His prior films, “The Witch” and “The Lighthouse,” both feature a small cast and embrace environmental horror as terrifying events slowly pull the main ensemble apart. His reputation for his smaller scale and focus is partly why “The Northman” was so interesting upon its announcement — “The Northman” blows up Egger’s storytelling onto a massive scale. The locations, number of characters, and time period all dwarf his prior films. For the most part, Eggers steps up to the plate, succeeding in his ambition. “The Northman” will be available to watch in theaters April 22. 


Comments

Please note All comments are eligible for publication by The Rice Thresher.